Book Review: Nix The Tricks

I am – I confess – a professional purveyor of tricks. A mnemonic here, a shortcut there – whatever it takes to get my students the skills they need to get the grade they want.

As such, I wasn’t expecting to enjoy Nix The Tricks, a free e-book offering alternatives to some common rules of thumb; I was expecting everything I do to be ruthlessly shot down. I was one step away from getting the Mathematical Ninja to hunt the authors down, just in case.

To everyone’s relief, though, the book is good. It even picks up on some of my major bugbears: the deadly minus-and-a-minus-makes-a-plus, the problematic PEMDAS (or BODMAS, as we call it here), the ‘moving’ model for linear algebra, the distance formula… all of these are taken down in roughly the same way as I would.

I’m completely in agreement with the idea that students should have a deep understanding of how maths works if they want to go on to do work that relies on it. I even agree with the case for teaching understanding from the start.

However, there are two problems the book brushes under the carpet: firstly, it implicitly assumes there’s enough slack in the curriculum that teachers have time to teach the deep stuff; and secondly, it ignores the problem that students – like all good mathematicians – are short-sighted and lazy. Almost every GCSE student I’ve ever met would prefer – and get better results from – a trick method of expanding brackets (FOIL, crab claws, smiley face) over learning the distributive law. Certainly at GCSE, where two-terms-in-a-bracket is the worst it ever gets, FOIL is unobjectionable (in that it’s memorable, and tends not to get messed up very often). If I have a student who knows how to use FOIL competently, I’m not going to spend half a class fixing something that isn’t broken.

Indeed, if I think back to how I learned (and learn) maths, I’ve always learned tricks first and got the deep understanding afterwards – if I was interested enough.

Still: as a blueprint for how maths skills ought to be taught, Nix the Tricks is a great, thought-provoking effort. I imagine it’ll get some slightly defensive reactions, like mine, and some very positive ones; in any event, it’s definitely worth a read. (It comes in at about 64 pages on my Kindle, so it’s hardly War and Peace.)

One thing I did take from the book was the idea that ‘cancel’ is a very dangerous word. Errors in simplifying fractions are a terrible scourge, and the idea of saying “No – you need to multiply or divide the top and bottom by the same thing” should make life a lot easier.


Colin is a Weymouth maths tutor, author of several Maths For Dummies books and A-level maths guides. He started Flying Colours Maths in 2008. He lives with an espresso pot and nothing to prove.


5 comments on “Book Review: Nix The Tricks

  • crstn85

    I hear you about the time constraint issue but I believe if students were taught material they were ready for and learned it well, we could do less “review” each year. I know testing pressure doesn’t always let us meet kids where they are though.

    As for FOIL being fine because all you do is multiply binomials – what about kids who continue in math? I tried to get teachers from all grade levels to contribute to this, most of these tricks are “sufficient for my class” but cause issues later.

    Thanks so much for reading and sharing!

    • Colin

      I don’t believe I said it was fine 😉 My point is, there are generally higher-value problems to fix before undoing something that works in practice. I actually quite enjoy showing how FOIL fits into a bigger framework, but I’d prefer to do it as it becomes a problem.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sign up for the Sum Comfort newsletter and get a free e-book of mathematical quotations.

No spam ever, obviously.

Where do you teach?

I teach in my home in Abbotsbury Road, Weymouth.

It's a 15-minute walk from Weymouth station, and it's on bus routes 3, 8 and X53. On-road parking is available nearby.

On twitter